British Columbia DSM
May 23, 2012, 11:13:24 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News:
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: PowerTrain Technology PTT Twin Disk Clutch in a 2G daily driver  (Read 852 times)
Tony Leong
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 238


1995 Eagle Talon TSi AWD 5spd


« on: September 19, 2009, 10:41:13 PM »

I hope I can answer some questions you may have if you are considering a PowerTrain Technology 7.25" Power-V racing clutch for your daily driven 2G.

How about if I answer this?  “I'm curious to know what it’s like to drive in heavy traffic or parking with a twin disk clutch.”

IMHO, the PowerTrain Technology 7.25" Power-V racing clutch (PTT) is a joy to daily drive.  Parallel parking is the same as a stock clutch.  However, I needed to learn about the nature of this clutch and gain some skill (see paragraphs below).  Also, it is noisy, stalls easily and may not last long in a daily driver.  Eventually, driving on the PTT becomes a skillset, something that I became used to and now it’s one of those things I do automatically, like shifting & using my turn signal.  It always, most importantly, put a huge smile on face after every driving opportunity.

First the “negatives”:

* I could have sworn there were pieces of loose gravel being ground up by gear teeth (see harmonics points a) & b) below)
* driveline harmonics can set off the CEL (DTC code says it’s a misfire)
* harmonics occurs when:
       a) lightly loading the transmission, for example, while coasting in gear on flat roads and/or slight downgrades or
       b) decelerating
* if the harmonics are allowed to grow in intensity, then the knock sensor retards ignition timing (learn to foresee this and get ready to either depress the clutch pedal or give it some gas).  This only had to happen to me once, and I have never let it occur since.
* in my case, a Fluidampr p/n 630701 harmonic dampener did not eliminate harmonics, but reduced it by 75% and rock crushing noises are now very low and muted
* stalls easily
* sounds like dishes rattling together when the clutch is disengaged (I personally don’t find this to be a negative)
* chair scraping sounds are made whenever engine and transmission RPMs aren’t matched on a downshift (I personally don’t find this to be a negative)
* I found myself concentrating more rather than driving along distracted (I personally find this to be an advantage) – matching engine/trans RPMs, listening for & avoiding harmonics, etc.
* small clutch engagement window, about 1/2” to 5/8”
* from a dead stop, it requires slipping the clutch 1,750RPM to 2,000RPM on level roads
* clutch started to slip1 at 12,000 Kilometers (7,440 miles) of daily driving
* Updated 31 October 2009 when these clutches begin to slip, it rapidly deteriorates
* Updated 31 October 2009  compared to a stock pressure plate, an extra 10 lbs. to 12 lbs. of foot pressure is needed to depress the clutch

In return for all of the above, I got these advantages:

* fast shifts
* smooth shifts
* no missed shifts
* always goes into gear no matter what the engine's RPM or road speed
* throttle response - blip the throttle and the engine responds almost as quickly as a motorcycle's does
* no chatter
* no stumbling
* raspy sounds of the PTT disengaged, while up shifting or parallel parking is just different from the sounds other cars make.  Yes, I like the sound of twin disk clutches.  I listen for other cars if they have it.
* main reason I chose a twin disk clutch – the PTT is less likely to over burden the crank shaft thrust bearing & crank walk the 4G63 engine


1 I’ve probably worn one or both PTT organic clutch disks to less than 0.185” (0.20” new).  PTT’s web site says that QuarterMaster, AP Racing & Tilton clutch disks can be used in their twin disk setup.  PTT e-mailed saying they will rebuild the twin disk for free; there will be no labour charges.

Configuration & operating environment notes:

The PowerTrain Technology 7.25" Power-V racing clutch is supposed to require a shorter range of movement by installing a slave cylinder from an Isuzu truck.  I used a new 2G Mitsubishi Eclipse OEM slave and did not grind the new OEM fork or shim the new OEM pivot ball to make the twin disk fit/engage/disengage.  The slave cylinder restrictor and accumulator (fluid collection unit) were removed.  A single, steel braided line from RRE replaced the OEM rubber lines.

Update 31 October 2009 I provided a new PTT throw out bearing back in October 2008, but something else had been substituted as the mechanic at the time said the PTT TOB “exploded”.  The substitute TOB’s height was shorter and had less metal overall than another new Mits OEM unit I just had installed (by another shop).  This could explain why I could get by on an OEM TOB and did not need an Isuzu slave cylinder.

The cruise control switch was backed out all the way until I could not start the car (safety switch is in there to prevent starting the Talon while in gear).  The switch was then moved forward, but only enough to start the Talon.  This placed the clutch pedal at its highest point, 6 1/2" from the floor.  According to my shop manual, this is still not the specified 7” from the floor.  Since I don't like the pedal that high, I put it back down to 5" off the floor (estimated).  There is one more step to do, please see Jack’s Transmission’s video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYJxQyjIhUw

When the clutch was new, I revved the motor to 5,500RPM while in first gear, clutch pedal pressed in a down, or clutch disengaged position with the e-brake off and the car did not creep forward.  I know this test should be pushed to 7,500RPM, but an unloaded motor spinning at red-line is just not my cup of tea.

For this review, a point to consider is that my Talon is a full weight, stock powered AWD with a Quaife ATB front LSD & an EVO 1st gear.  The EVO is 10% taller than stock.  Jack’s Transmissions also double synchro’d 1st, 2nd & 3rd gears and upgraded the trans for the twin disks’ harmonics.

I love that that EVO 1st gear!  According to my 1995 sales brochure, stock Turbos make a peak 214 ft. lbs. at 3,000RPM.  By the time the clutch is let out fully at 2,000RPMs, the 4G63 is less than 1,000RPMs from peak torque by the time the car begins to inch forward.  The car wants leap forward all the time.

I can usually be found during rush hour inching up to four way stops on mountainous roads and also crawling slowly to queue up for bridge traffic.  The twin disk is always being slipped.  Sometimes I will smell clutch burning while stop & going.
Short clutch life requires steep grades + stop & go traffic + light flywheel + taller 1st gear + Quaife front/4 spider centre/viscous rear LSDs + full weight AWD.

Summary:

I have not set off the CEL for a long time.  Even my wife doesn’t set off the CEL anymore (she never got the 2G to retard the ignition).  Both of our skills using the PTT had to improve and that was all.

Remember, as always, your mileage may vary from my observations/experiences.

Updated 19 Dec 2009 Crank shaft thrust bearing wear with the PTT was 0.002” after 12,000Kms.  The crank shaft end-play was 0.003” when the PTT went in and 0.005” shortly after the PTT was pulled out.  This measurement was done by a Mitsu dealer.
« Last Edit: December 31, 2009, 12:29:40 PM by Tony Leong » Logged
Brett Haviland
Hero Member
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 5126



« Reply #1 on: September 22, 2009, 05:10:52 PM »

Is the disk surface a metalic material??   (never mind... read through the whole post... seen that they are orgnaic.)

If so i have seen the disks actually wear down the flywheel and pressure plate metal causing it to not clamp hard enough... pull it apart and machine the flywheel and PP (or just replace the PP) and then its good to go for another years of abuse.

This is on the metalic 6 pucks clutch disks that i have used..  I have used the same disk on my colt for the last 4 years...  it will start slipping so i just pop the trans off... machine the flywheel down and replace the pressure plate... (maybe you can machine the PP as well???)... put it back together and its like new again untill it wears down again... eventually you cant machine the flywheel anymore tho and its useless... THis is where the aftermarket flywheels with the replaceable surfaces come in handy.
« Last Edit: September 22, 2009, 05:13:12 PM by Brett Haviland » Logged

I like Colts.  Turbo Colts.
Tony Leong
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 238


1995 Eagle Talon TSi AWD 5spd


« Reply #2 on: September 25, 2009, 12:56:20 AM »

Thanks Brett.

When I pull it, I'll send it to Pwertrain Technology for a repair/assessment.

P.S. - I updated the review to make it more useful to BC DSMers.
Logged
Cole MacDonald
Senior Member
Hero Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 1054



WWW
« Reply #3 on: October 28, 2009, 10:42:00 PM »

Any updates on this? I'm looking into twin disk setups and am interested to hear the rest of the story. Thanks
Logged

1990 FWD Laser 240 FWHP
1993 AWD Laser, 2.4L GT35r powered 562 AWHP
2008 Dodge Ram 3500 6.7L Cummins
2012 Skidoo Summit Everest 800 E Tech 164HP
Tony Leong
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 238


1995 Eagle Talon TSi AWD 5spd


« Reply #4 on: October 31, 2009, 11:12:38 PM »

I am waiting for an RMA# from PTT USA.  I will report their findings when that information becomes available.

Also, I updated my original post.  While the PTT is out of the Talon, I am now running a Mits OEM pressure plate, Mits OEM TOB, ACT unsprung Street disk p/n 3000310 and an RRE 11.25lb. chrome-moly flywheel.  I am able to provide a better comparison between stock vs. twin disk clutches, for example, I can't believe how easy it is to depress the clutch, when I previously, and mistakenly, thought the PTT had a stock plus 5-8lb. clutch pedal pressure.
« Last Edit: December 20, 2009, 04:23:17 AM by Tony Leong » Logged
Ivan Skare
Hero Member
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 1064


« Reply #5 on: November 01, 2009, 01:54:11 AM »

Stick to single disk setup if your cars a daily driver.

Twin disk is overkill.
Logged

604 375 4192. Call me anytime.
Tony Leong
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 238


1995 Eagle Talon TSi AWD 5spd


« Reply #6 on: December 20, 2009, 05:11:09 AM »

I updated my original post with a more complete review.

Highlights of my conversation with PTT’s Steve Fox:

Clutch assembly had all the signs of an over-heated clutch.

The clutch pack was worn.  I had also warped the pressure plate & one steel ring.

The pressure plate clamping force is likely reduced due to damage caused by the use of a Mits OEM slave cylinder rather than the recommended Isuzu slave cylinder.

PTT recommends the Isuzu slave cylinder.  The Mits slave cylinder usually pushes the pressure plate fingers past their full engagement point.  However, Steve noted the pressure plate fingers showed no signs of contacting the clutch disk closest to the transmission, and that clutch disk was not bent.  The pressure plate could lose some of its clamping capability from over-extension and this would be checked.  I have not yet received a response if the pressure plate is no longer clamping at its rated 600 lbs of torque.

The Isuzu slave would have given a larger engagement window and the improved modulation would have made street drivability much easier.

The PTT throw out bearing (TOB) does not need a lot a pressure to press the Mitsu TOB backing plate onto the PTT TOB.  However, there are variations in Mitsu OEM TOBs, so may be it did explode due to a bad fit.

Summary:

The PTT clutch is not designed for street use.  I was not using it for its intended purpose.

Consumer response:

Auld Dawgs like me don’t learn well – I miss the PTT.
Logged
Lowell Foo
Senior Member
Hero Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 780


WWW
« Reply #7 on: December 24, 2009, 06:08:07 PM »

Stick to single disk setup if your cars a daily driver.

Twin disk is overkill.

I just put down 494whp on an ACT2600/street disc combo.  Smooth and quiet with zero chatter =) 
Logged

92 Laser AWD, 50 trim, 494whp
92 Talon AWD, 50 trim, 11.55 @ 127mph w/ 399whp.
90 Talon AWD, 11.40 @ 123 ~ 10 years ago.  Currently in storage.
patrickWoo
Guest
« Reply #8 on: January 23, 2010, 01:01:27 PM »

yah typically the twin clutch are for heavy clutch dumpers like drifters and such...

AWD launch only once in a while need not apply.
Logged
Scott Girvin
Hero Member
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 2504



« Reply #9 on: January 27, 2010, 03:34:06 AM »

I was pondering the idea of a twin disc but decided against it since I DD the car in the summer. I went with the ACT2900 /w sprung 6 puck. Suprisingly, the 2900 has less pedal pressure than my old 2600 I had a couple years ago. Still working on break-in.
Logged
Brett Haviland
Hero Member
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 5126



« Reply #10 on: January 28, 2010, 03:49:42 PM »

Yeah i read on here that the 2900 has more fingers in the PP so it distributes the spring load more evenly to the throwout bearing/hydrolic system causing a lighter pedal feel then the 2600 which has less fingers on the PP, eventho the 2900 has more clamping force.

Seems pretty cool to me! 
Logged

I like Colts.  Turbo Colts.
Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.16 | SMF © 2011, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!